SPME Petition 25

Message Regarding "Resolution in Support of University of California San Diego Corporate Accountability through Divestment from Corporations Profiting from the Illegal Occupation, Siege, and Blockade of Palestine"


Dear ASUCSD President Le and Council Members:

Regarding: "Resolution in Support of University of California San Diego Corporate Accountability through Divestment from Corporations Profiting from the Illegal Occupation, Siege, and Blockade of Palestine,"

We the undersigned strongly urge you to reject the above referenced resolution which unfairly singles out the State of Israel. Though we have diverse opinions on the best way to resolve the tragic conflict between Israel and Palestinians, we are all united in our opinion that this resolution is profoundly misguided, misleading, and unworthy of endorsement by a representative body that has been entrusted to reflect the interests of UCSD's students.

This resolution uses specious arguments that rely on selective, de-contextualized and misrepresented facts to falsely cast Israel as a rogue human rights violator while sidestepping any Palestinian culpability for the strife that has scarred both peoples for far too long. It is particularly revealing that this resolution completely ignores the abysmal human rights situations that exist among Israel's neighbors, such as Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and within the Palestinian ruled territories, and focuses exclusively on the one nation whose record of protecting the civil liberties and democratic freedoms of all its citizens is consistently ranked the highest among the nations of the Mideast.

The most troubling aspect of the resolution is its characterization of Jewish citizens of Israel as "colonial occupiers" while Arabs are described as indigenous to the land.  In so doing, the resolution denies the profound emotional, cultural, and religious connection of the Jewish people to the land of Israel, a connection that spans 3000 years. This is a deplorable attempt to delegitimize an ancient people's ethnic identity. Rather than advancing the prospect of reconciliation between Arabs and Jews, such claims regress to the very attitude that has been at the heart of the conflict and prevented a peaceful resolution thus far.

In conclusion, we call on you, the elected student leadership of UCSD, to recognize the resolution before you for what it truly is – a partisan attempt to bolster the narrative of one party to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict at the expense of the other. This resolution does not genuinely seek to educate or to redress injustice. Likewise, it does nothing to advance a just and peaceful solution to the tragic conflict that would address the legitimate aspiration of both peoples. Rather, this disingenuous resolution seeks to achieve a political victory for one side over the other. The adoption of this biased resolution by ASUCSD would be a lasting stain on the reputation of ASUCSD and UCSD and it would deal a heavy blow to efforts to foster a respectful and tolerant climate on this campus.

We wish you great wisdom in dealing with this issue!






103 signatures

Share this with your friends:


Latest Signatures
103Dr Gabriel Ike ObiefunaOct 22, 2018
102Anwesha SenToronto, CanadaJan 21, 2016
101Mathew DiamondUdine, ItalyJan 14, 2016
100Hinda BlasPetalumaJan 12, 2016
99Prof. Doron LubinskyAtlantaAug 10, 2014
98Cecille SantosMay 01, 2014
97Professor Raphael MarcusMontreal, CanadaAug 29, 2013
96Jj NielsonOgden, UtahJul 22, 2013
95Stephen Rubin Fairfield, CT 06825May 20, 2013
94Dafna Yee Texas, USAApr 21, 2013
93Marianne Dacy SydneyApr 15, 2013
92Bruce Cohen Sydney AustraliaApr 14, 2013
91Zvi Wirschubsky Apr 14, 2013
90Harry Geduld Indiana, U.S.A.Apr 13, 2013
89ernest Newbrun San Francisco CAApr 11, 2013
88Roberta Dzubow Plymouth MeetingApr 10, 2013
87Theodore Eisenberg Beer-Sheva/ISRAELApr 10, 2013
86Peter Browne Jönköping, SwedenApr 10, 2013
85Ari Elson israelApr 10, 2013
84philip freedman nyApr 10, 2013
83Ralph Ross Leeds EnglandApr 10, 2013
82selma brandow camp hill paApr 10, 2013
81Joyce Ladenson MichiganApr 10, 2013
80Christiane Toft Apr 09, 2013
79Alvin Faierman Apr 09, 2013
78gail wadeson Apr 09, 2013
77Michael Sommer Wyoming, USAApr 09, 2013
76Hava Mendelberg Apr 09, 2013
75ruth n holt southbury,connecticutApr 09, 2013
74Louis Goldstein Winston Salem NC/USAApr 09, 2013
73Trevor Welsh Newcastle upon TyneApr 09, 2013
72Jason Rosenfeld Apr 09, 2013
71Albert Elmaleh Apr 09, 2013
70Allan Berele USAApr 09, 2013
69David Rosenberg Apr 09, 2013
68richard chazkel Apr 09, 2013
67Daniel Prober New Haven, CT 06520Apr 09, 2013
66Luize Zubrow Apr 09, 2013
65Shlomo Dubnov, PhD Chula VistaApr 05, 2013
64David Muir LondonMar 28, 2013
63Daniel Arovas San DiegoMar 15, 2013
62Jon Schuller Mar 15, 2013
61Jeffrey Max San Diego, CAMar 14, 2013
60David Kleinfeld La Jolla, CAMar 14, 2013
59Benjamin Grinstein Mar 14, 2013
58Avi Yagil CaliforniaMar 14, 2013
57Saul Oseroff San Diego, CA USMar 14, 2013
56Susan Powell San Diego, CAMar 14, 2013
55Matan Shelomi CAMar 13, 2013
54Nitzan Bluvstein Mar 13, 2013
53Jacqueline Zelener Mar 13, 2013
52Katherine Sherman Mar 13, 2013
51Leedan Trau Mar 13, 2013
50Danny Eliahu Mar 13, 2013
49Andrew Kuban Agoura HillsMar 13, 2013
48Navid Elie Mar 13, 2013
47Samuel Asin Palo AltoMar 13, 2013
46Robbie Zarem Mar 13, 2013
45Ethan Spiro CAMar 13, 2013
44David Marias Mar 13, 2013
43Edward Rabin Mar 12, 2013
42Eve Wurtele AmesMar 11, 2013
41Lisa Feierman San Clemente, CAMar 11, 2013
40yahli lorch Mar 11, 2013
39David Feifel La JollaMar 11, 2013
38Gabriella Dakteris Mission Viejo, CAMar 11, 2013
37Lara Grines Mar 11, 2013
36Elizabeth Twamley Mar 10, 2013
35Michaela Fried CAMar 10, 2013
34Micha Adler Los AngelesMar 10, 2013
33Ariel Fridman Mar 10, 2013
32Aaron bloch Thousand OaksMar 10, 2013
31Moran Goren Mar 10, 2013
30Benjamin Katz CaliforniaMar 10, 2013
29john felstiner Stanford, CAMar 10, 2013
28Gabi Tripolsky Redwood City, CAMar 10, 2013
27Ilana Grines Mar 10, 2013
26Alexandra Kantor Mar 10, 2013
25Shlomo Dubnov San DiegoMar 10, 2013
24Ronald Mehler NorthridgeMar 10, 2013
23Robert Adler Los AngelesMar 10, 2013
22Gregory Light Mar 10, 2013
21Victoria Risbrough CAMar 10, 2013
20Pamela Cosman La JollaMar 10, 2013
19Sidney Zisook Mar 10, 2013
18Cherryl Smith Mar 10, 2013
17Neal Swerdlow La Jolla, CAMar 10, 2013
16Sandor Reichman Los Angeles, Ca.Mar 10, 2013
15Kenneth J. Arrow CaliforniaMar 10, 2013
14Leslie Bernstein Sherman Oaks, CA, USAMar 10, 2013
13Robert Cole Berkeley CAMar 10, 2013
12Jonathan Berger Mar 10, 2013
11Stanley Brodsky United StatesMar 10, 2013
10Jeffrey Ullman StanfordMar 10, 2013
9Dor Abrahamson BerkeleyMar 09, 2013
8Mordecai Kurz Mar 09, 2013
7Itzhak Bars Arcadia, CA, USAMar 09, 2013
6Davida Fischman CaliforniaMar 09, 2013
5Joanne Altschuler Mar 09, 2013
4Melvin Breuer CA, USAMar 09, 2013