College is too late. Jewish day schools have made strides in ratcheting up Israel education with support from groups like The David Project. It’s time we expand our reach to youth groups and camps, which could use an Israel booster. They are ideal places to instill Israel identity, articulate the meaning of Israel to the Jewish people, and expand knowledge. Concerted efforts could also help overcome the disappointing apathy that is all too common among young Jews.
Birthright and MASA programs, among others, have been highly successful in instilling a connection to Israel and strengthening Jewish identity. For the purposes of creating activism on campus, however, it’s imperative that we send as many kids as possible to Israel early in their college careers. A trip during junior year leaves only one year left. Send us your sophomores!
Pro-Israel organizations have often treated campus like Capitol Hill or CNN, relying on talking points and advocacy approaches appropriate for a completely different political environment. Most students won’t be in front of a camera any time soon. While the talking points we use to speak with members of Congress are great for mainstream elected officials, they will likely turn off student leaders from diverse ethnic and cultural groups.
Every campus is different and every campus subgroup is different. How can students calibrate their message accordingly? Pro-Israel students at the University of Maryland, among the most effective in the country, recently organized a dinner with student leaders representing various groups from around campus, from the NAACP to student government. Jewish students brought in Israel experts to lead dialogue sessions about various aspects of Israel. Such a proactive model of engagement goes a long way in generating good will.
A dose of realism is in order. Given today’s prevailing “post-modern” intellectual milieu, coupled with Saudi funding for Middle East studies, we won’t claim the majority of the faculty brain trust any time soon. We can, however, help diversify approaches to teaching about Israel and make sure that supportive faculty are present on campus guiding students through challenges.
David Bernstein is the Executive Director of The David Project, a non-profit organization dedicated to educating and inspiring strong voices for Israel.