Presbyterians take antisemitic tone with BDS resolutions; new BDS threat from anthropologists

In June BDS activities took a dramatic turn as the Presbyterian Church-USA narrowly approved a limited Israel divestment resolution. The language and tone of the resolution and the accompanying debate, however, were strongly shaped by traditional Protestant supersessionism. The antisemitic basis of church-based BDS has become difficult to disguise and will shape coming debates over church-based divestment.

Analysis

With the end of the academic year BDS activism has shifted back to the churches. The General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church-USA (PC-USA) narrowly adopted a resolution that instructs the Presbyterian Foundation and Board of Pensions of the PC-USA to “divest from Caterpillar, Inc, Hewlett-Packard, and Motorola Solutions.” The resolution goes on to state, however, that “This action on divestment is not to be construed or represented by any organization of the PC (USA) as divestment from the State of Israel, or an alignment with or endorsement of the global BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) movement.” The statement also reaffirmed the church’s support for a two state solution.

BDS has a long history in PC-USA. A policy of “phased, selective divestment” from Israel was adopted in the 2004 General Assembly by a large margin. At the same time Christian Zionism was rejected as incompatible with Presbyterian theology. In 2006 the divestment language was replaced with a more positive call for engagement and development on both sides of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In 2012, however, the General Assembly called explicitly for boycotting Israeli enterprises in the West Bank.

In 2004 and 2005, as divestment resolutions in the guise of socially responsible investment were being debated within the PC-USA General Assembly, a controversy emerged when staff members organized a meeting of Presbyterian leaders with Hezbollah members in Lebanon. Engagement with the Muslim world, and especially with Palestinian Christians, has long been a PC-USA focus.

The influence of Palestinian Christian was seen in 2010 when the General Assembly instructed a study guide be prepared on the Kairos Palestine Document. The Kairos document is a Palestinian Christian implicit attack on the concepts of Jewish national identity and sovereignty in Israel and an explicit assault on Christian Zionism. It also describes “the occupation” as a sin, legitimizes violence as “resistance,” and calls for a South African style BDS campaign against Israel. It has gained enormous traction within left-leaning Protestant denominations including the Anglican and Methodist churches.

The 2014 vote came after a protracted period of debate that was shaped by lobbying on both sides of the issue. A subcommittee of the General Assembly had recommended the resolution and both there and at the General Assembly a number of BDS supporters had spoken in favor. These included Rifat Kassis, coordinator of Kairos Palestine, and Anna Balzer, national organizer for the US Campaign to End the Occupation. BDS activists were also involved in writing the resolution. The pro-BDS/pro-one state group ‘Jewish Voices for Peace’ apparently also played an important role. Though tiny, the group gave PC-USA cover to claim Jewish support for the divestment resolution.

The role of the PC-USA’s Middle East Issues Committee, Advisory Committee on Social Witness Policy, National Middle Eastern Presbyterian Caucus, and Israel/Palestine Mission Network in pushing BDS cannot be understated. These and other committees have long been centers for anti-Israel activism within PC-USA. The 2014 debate was also shaped by the Israel/Palestine Mission Network’s Zionism Unsettled document.

The “congregational study guide” is distributed widely by PC-USA. Among other things the document promotes the ideas that Jews were well treated in Arab countries and that hostility is the result of Zionism, and that Israel, supported by the US, oppresses and brutalizes Palestinians. It also relies on strongly anti-Zionist sources and contains numerous misrepresentations of history. Opposition to the document has come not only from Jewish but Presbyterian sources.

The debate was given a more explicit antisemitic tone by statements from participants, such as the vice moderator of the Middle East issues committee, who stated during morning devotions that ‘Jesus was not afraid to tell the Jews when they were wrong.’ Another BDS supporter attending the General Assembly posted on Facebook that “America is the Promised Land. We all know this. Come to the land of opportunity. Quit feeling guilt about what you are doing in Palestine, Jewish friends. Stop it. Come home to America!” The same individual also reposted an article celebrating the kidnapping of three Israeli teenagers.

The theological dimension was paramount throughout the General Assembly’s debates. The General Assembly rejected a proposal entitled “On Distinguishing Between Biblical Terms for Israel and Those Applied to the Modern Political State of Israel in Christian Liturgy” but added “we take the matter of language, and specifically the tension around the use of the term "Israel," very seriously. We hope the discussion and education about the use of language continues.”

PC-USA’s Advocacy Committee for Racial Ethnic Concerns, however, took the matter further and noted:

For many worshipers today, the word “Israel” has taken on political and military connotations and the original scriptural meanings are almost lost. Just as PC(USA) adopted inclusive and expansive language for racial and gender justice, ACREC believes it is important and timely to be intentional and well-informed with language that has taken on political meanings beyond the walls of church and worship.

Littlefield Presbyterian Church in Dearborn, MI has used the following paragraph for several years in their worship bulletin:

“ISRAEL” LANGUAGE IN WORSHIP—We want to be sensitive to the pain of our Palestinian-American friends and others when they encounter “Israel” in the language of scriptures, hymns and liturgy. In our worship, “Israel” is referring to ancient Israel, not the modern political state. At various times in history it meant the collective name of the twelve tribes descended from Jacob, “the people of Israel,” the nation of Israel as a whole, or, during the period of the Divided Monarch, to the Northern Kingdom. We want to be faithful hearers and interpreters of the scripture and recognize that Jesus was a Jew, a descendent of David, King of the United Monarchy, and that what we know as the Old Testament was Jesus’ scriptures.

On PALM SUNDAY, we need to remember that the people who waved palm branches in Jerusalem lived under the yoke of occupation and oppression by the Roman Empire. Over the centuries other oppressed peoples have identified with the plight and the longings of the people of Israel when they were enslaved, exiled, and occupied and also with the message of deliverance and freedom they found in the scriptures. We pray fervently for the day when the Palestinian people no longer live under occupation, a day when Palestinians and Israelis find a way to live together in peace, with justice for all.

This formula effectively casts modern Palestinians as the ‘new Jews’ under a modern Rome, Israel.

Largely unnoticed in the controversy surrounding the PC-USA’s divestment vote was another resolution that called for the organization to undertake research toward “a recommendation about whether the General Assembly should continue to call for a two-state solution in Israel Palestine, or take a neutral stance that seeks not to determine for Israelis and Palestinians what the right “solution” should be.” Such a recommendation, to be debated at the 2016 General Assembly, would likely result in the PC-USA following the lead of Palestinian Christians in calling for a one state solution. In addition, another resolution was adopted that condemned Israel for human rights violations and pervasive racism.

After the vote church leaders again took pains to publicly stress that the resolution did not mean the church backed the BDS movement and that Jews should not be offended by the move. The moderator of the General Assembly added that"in no way is this a reflection of our lack of love for our Jewish brothers and sisters."

Responses to the vote were swift, with condemnation from across the political and religious spectrum of Jewish organizations, as well as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Non-Jewish sources including Presbyterian also condemned the move. The resolution will have a negative impact on national and local Jewish-Presbyterian relations.

BDS supporters and self-proclaimed anti-Semites such as David Duke, far-right politician and former Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, offered congratulations to PC-USA for the resolution. Despite the PC-USA’s efforts to distance its decision from the broader BDS movement, Duke characterized their move more plainly as “Victory! Presbyterian Votes Israeli Divestment!”

Understanding the Presbyterian Church-USA’s decision is difficult. The movement has experienced a dramatic loss of membership in recent years while at the same time moving culturally and politically farther to the left. The 2014 General Assembly for example voted to allow same-sex marriage. The relationship between membership trends and cultural and political orientation is difficult to assess from the outside but has long been seen in rapidly shrinking Protestant denominations, especially the Anglicans.

At the same time, unlike historic “peace churches” such as the Quakers, which have long been on the left politically and strongly anti-Israel, but which lack well-developed theology, PC-USA appears to be reemphasizing traditional Protestant supersessionist attitudes and rhetoric. The elevation of the Palestinian Christian narrative of its own suffering and Israeli’s evil, the pains taken to distinguish modern Israel from Old and New Testament Israel, and efforts to expunge the term ‘Israel’ from both, meld traditional and modern antisemitism. The support given the church by David Duke and others also show again that the far left and the far right in America are converging on the issue of opposing Israel.

Several BDS developments marked the end of the academic year. The University of California, Santa Cruz student government passed a divestment resolution. In an observation that speaks to the non-grassroots nature of academic BDS campaigns one opponent noted “On the other side, there was a large number of students. This is an undergraduate student assembly supposed to represent undergrads at Santa Cruz. It’s not a place for somebody who graduated 40 years ago.”

The membership of the Modern Language Association rejected a resolution condemning Israel for allegedly restricting the movement of Palestinian academics. In online voting the resolution failed to receive the minimum of 10% of votes from the membership for passage. Only 6% of the membership voted in favor but a leading BDS supporter mysteriously characterized this as indicating "MLA members showed that they were 60 percent in favor of such a resolution." The vote came after many months of public debate, including at the annual MLA meeting, and strongly organized opposition to the resolution.

The American Anthropological Association (AAA) has now has requested input from its members for an “informed” position on “Israel-Palestine.” The request explicitly sets this request in the context of academic BDS efforts and states “that a boycott is not the only possible AAA response, should the AAA choose to act. Without prejudicing an open-ended conversation, we present some alternatives to a boycott that have been proposed or can be imagined” including condemnation and divestment. The request was put forward by the president, vice-president and executive director of the organization, allegedly at the request of members.

The debate within the AAA has thus been shaped in a way that guarantees BDS activists will dominate the flow of information toward the goal of adopting BDS resolutions. The organization has a long tradition of taking political positions on various issues.

Two developments in the arts world point to new types of BDS related pressure in this area. A Pittsburgh art show bringing together Israeli, Palestinian and American artists was cancelled shortly before opening when the Palestinians withdrew. The gallery posted an apology on its web site directed “to all Palestinians everywhere for the misunderstanding of this exhibition.”

The nature of the “misunderstanding” was revealed in another web posting which noted “This show was never intended to be about normalization.” The term “normalization” is used by Palestinians to denote any form of cooperation with Israelis that suggest acceptance of Israel’s existence or rights, or that Israel is a “normal” state.

In another case a traveling art show was attacked for exhibiting at the Technion Institute in Israel. A newly created BDS group approached participating artists to request that “cultural organizations must halt their partnerships with institutions that contribute to or normalize the Israeli military-industrial complex.” The curator responded that the organizing group does not support BDS or participate in boycotts.

Both incidents show that the arts world will emerge as a new front for BDS campaigns, directed at individual artists, collectives, curators and galleries.

The sports world also saw another attack on Israel with sanctions overtones. The Palestinian Football Federation complained to the FIFA Congress, the global football association, about Israeli restrictionson the movement of Palestinian players. The possibility of expelling Israel from FIFA was raised but the organization insteaddecided to create a committeeto monitor Israeli treatment of Palestinian players. Palestinians and Arab countries have long sought to expel Israel from international sports.

At least onecommentator noted that FIFA’s focus on Israel is bizarre, particularly in light of the immense bribery scandal surrounding the award of the 2022 World Cup to Qatar and the hundreds of deaths of workers constructing the Qatari stadium, in addition to match-rigging and other scandals.

Finally, despite heavy BDS pressure,the Rolling Stones performed a sold out show in Israel and other artists are scheduled or are in negotiations to appear. In contrast, Irish singer Sinead O’Connor has announced that she will attempt to cancela scheduled performance in Israel. She stated “I was not informed by my booking agent, and was unaware myself, that a boycott of Israel had been requested by the Palestinian people.” She added "I do not appreciate being bullied by anyone on either side of this debate any more than I appreciate not being properly informed by my booking agent of the potential ramifications of accepting work in war zones."

Read more.

Middle East Conflict, U.S. Campuses

It was an exceptionally busy academic year for pro-Palestinian student activism on campus. The American Studies Association's December resolution to endorse the academic boycott of Israel got an extraordinary amount of ink, but arguably it was the students, not their professors, who led the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) push against Israel on campuses this year. Student government associations at well over …

Read more.

Anti-Semites Rock Colleges

Members of a pro-Palestine student organization are trying to stifle pro-Israel views and terrorize Jewish students across the nation. A slew of anti-Semitic online postings by Vassar College’s chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine have brought the group under investigation by school administrators. One post included an old Nazi propaganda political cartoon entitled “Liberators,” which depicts a monster representing …

Read more.

Pro-Palestinian students bring hate, intimidation to campus, critics say

They've become the bullies of the quad at college campuses around the nation, shouting down speakers, terrorizing Jewish students and intimidating those who disagree with them on the vexing issue of peace in the Middle East, according to watchdog groups. Students for Justice in Palestine, with nearly 100 chapters on campuses around the nation, has become increasing strident in promoting …

Read more.

France warns citizens against doing business in settlements

France warns citizens against doing business in settlements

A view of the settlement of Kiryat Arba, in the southern West Bank, adjoining the city of Hebron. (photo credit: Michal Fattal/Flash90) The French government released a public message to its citizens Tuesday warning against conducting business or investing in Israeli settlements in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Golan Heights. The French Foreign Ministry wrote in the statement that …

Read more.

Dutch Pension Fund PGGM Reportedly Regrets Divesting From Israeli Markets

Dutch pension fund giant PGGM now regrets a decision in January to divest from five Israeli banks, according to Dutch fund managers cited by the Financial Times, as part of a wider review of how pension funds and fund managers now view the campaign to divest from Israeli companies, or international companies active in the West Bank. As recently as March, …

Read more.

In 2013, Norway Government Pension Fund Investment in Israeli Stock Market Rose 43% to $1 Billion

The Government Pension Fund of Norway, the largest sovereign wealth fund in the world, has increased its position in shares of Israeli companies, adding five new companies to a portfolio of 62 stocks valued at a billion dollars (NIS 3.5 billion) on the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange, Israel’s Globes business daily reported on Tuesday. In 2013, the value of its …

Read more.

Palestinians: BDS Activists Are Troublemakers, Criminals

The Palestinian Authority's move against the BDS activists shows that it considers the movement a threat to Palestinian interests.A Palestinian Authority official in Ramallah explained that BDS and its followers make the Palestinians appear as if they are all radicals who are only interested in boycotting and delegitimizing Israel."No, we do not support the boycott of Israel." — Mahmoud Abbas, …

Read more.

To perform or not to perform in Israel? Here’s how it went for 10 Western artists

JERUSALEM – A movement that encourages boycotts of Israel, its products and institutions has had some success, particularly in raising awareness about the situation of Palestinians who live in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and in the besieged Gaza Strip. Formally known as the boycott, divestment and sanctions – or BDS – movement, it demands that Israel end the occupation, grant …

Read more.

First proactive anti-BDS student resolution passes at Western Washington U.

(JNS.org) Associated Students of Western Washington University (ASWWU) became the first North American university student government to pass a proactive resolution against the anti-Israel Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement. In a 7-0 vote, ASWWU resolved that it would not consider BDS resolutions based on national origin because “tensions between students related to foreign conflicts should be managed in a …

Read more.

I'm a Rabbi and I Support Presbyterian Israel Divestment

Jewish divestment advocates at the Presbyterian Church’s General Assembly in 2012 / JVP A few years ago I was walking in the woods with a friend, a minister in the Dutch Reformed Church in Cape Town, South Africa. The Dutch Reformed Church was the leading promulgator of apartheid in South Africa, and they upheld the odious doctrine both politically and …

Read more.

In Their Silence, Israeli Academics Collude With Occupation

In Their Silence, Israeli Academics Collude With Occupation

Ariel U., an Israeli institution in the West Bank, was granted university status in 2012. Photographs by Rina Castelnuovo, Redux. n 2006, I was among 25 professors from five Israeli universities who filed a petition with the High Court of Justice in Israel requesting that the court put a stop to the transformation of a small college, located in the …

Read more.

Washington Post’ reports that funders have excommunicated Jews who don’t believe in Zionism

Shondes, fronted by Louisa Solomon Marc Fisher has an excellent piece up at the Washington Post on the cracks beginning to show inside the official Washington Jewish community over Israel, with young Jews saying they do not believe in the need for a Jewish state, and in doing so, fostering an argument. The Post piece is exceptional for its openness …

Read more.

Kick Israel out of FIFA (graphic: Stephanie Westbrook)

Tell FIFA to dump Israel now, urges international campaign

The congress of FIFA, the International Football Federation, is meeting Tuesday and Wednesday in Sao Paulo, and the international campaign to have Israel kicked out of the organization for longtime human rights abuses and violations of international law is swinging into full gear right now. Kick Israel out of FIFA (graphic: Stephanie Westbrook) As we’ve been reporting for months, Jibril Rajoub, …

Read more.

International Keynote speakers at two Israeli conferences withdraw in reaction to BDS calls!

The recent success of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement in deterring leading academics from participating in Israeli conferences is a marked move forward towards removing academic respectability from Israeli institutions, and persuading more academics to refrain from collaborating with the Israeli occupation and apartheid regime. Two conferences scheduled for June 2014 have now lost their intended keynote and …

Read more.

A Wicked Act

The world’s organized hostility to Israel would be kind of funny if it didn’t have such serious consequences, or potential consequences. There are some 200 nations in the world. Many of them are very bad actors: dictatorships, terror states. And it is tiny, democratic Israel that is the focus of the world’s hostility. The latest is that the Presbyterian Church …

Read more.

Presbyterians Have It Back-to-Front on Zionism

In the neighborhood of Kerem Hateymanim, the bougainvillea spill out over the terraces. The one-story homes, built higgledy-piggledy, jostle for space. Here, like in much of south Tel Aviv, outsiders have been buying up property as the area undergoes inevitable gentrification. But in the beginning, the neighborhood was constructed out of wooden beams and tin roofs by desperately poor Jews …

Read more.

The Presbyterian Speech We Needed To Hear

Anger. Sadness. Disappointment. Even disgust. Those are the emotions that have accompanied the recent resolution of the Presbyterian Church USA to divest from the three companies – Motorola, Caterpillar, and HP – that the church deems to be complicit in the occupation of the West Bank. With this close vote, PCUSA essentially, though perhaps unwittingly, threw its lot in with …

Read more.

Portrait of a Presbyterian divestment activist

Robert Ross is the son of a Presbyterian minister from West Virginia and currently an assistant professor of global cultural studies at Point Park University in Pittsburgh. He graduated from West Chester State University in Pennsylvania, majoring in sociology and anthropology, and earned his M.A. and Ph.D. in Geography from the University of London and from Syracuse University. He then …

Read more.

Let It Bleed

LONDON — The Rolling Stones played Tel Aviv last week. It being Israel, this was a political event. Roger Waters and Nick Mason, founding members of Pink Floyd, were vociferous in invoking Israeli “apartheid” as they tried to stop Mick Jagger, Keith Richards et al. from holding their concert June 4. “Playing Israel now is the moral equivalent of playing …

Read more.

For academic freedom and against BDS

I had the pleasure of speaking at Gratz College outside Philadelphia last week. The topic was, once again, the academic boycott of Israel, followed by a Q&A session. For those of you near Los Angeles, I’ll be speaking at the invitation of Children of Jewish Holocaust Survivors – Los Angeles, co-sponsored by the Horowitz Freedom Center.

Read more.

Op-Ed: BDS, DePaul U. and Hypocrisy

After months of campaigning, the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement at Chicago’s DePaul University held a referendum on the issue. Only a small fraction of DePaul students actually voted and the resolution passed by a small margin, saying less about sentiment on campus than the passion of the small groups of students involved. It was a Pyrrhic victory. As …

Read more.

Why Are Student Leaders and Jewish Bruins Under Attack at UCLA?

Why Are Student Leaders and Jewish Bruins Under Attack at UCLA?

Photo: Marc Levin / flickr There will always be that one person who does not like you. There will always be that one person who thinks you can do no right. And while you acknowledge your own faults, that one person sees them as far greater than anyone else’s. Implicit in this is the antagonistic relationship between two people, between …

Read more.

Pro-Israel Muslim Vassar student’s lonely fight to defend Israel

I graduated from Vassar College in May 2014.  I was the President of the Vassar Conservative Libertarian Union, and the anti-Israel fervor found me. Before we go into this sordid story, it gives us perspective on the times to remember that Vassar College was once a great friend of Israel. In 1975, “Students React Quickly to U.N. Zionism Vote” was a …

Read more.

Officers

John R. Cohn, MD
Vice President

 

Staff

Alex Joffe, PhD
Editor, SPME BDS Monitor

Asaf Romirowsky, PhD
Executive Director
SPME Faculty Forum, Editor